|
|
Using Evidence |
Using Evidence to Make Tradeoffs |
|
Score |
Response uses objective reason(s) based on relevant evidence to argue for or against an option. |
Response recognizes multiple perspectives of issue and explains each perspective using objective reasons, supported by evidence, in order to make choice. |
|---|---|---|
|
4 |
Accomplishes Level 3 AND goes beyond in some significant way, such as questioning or justifying the source, validity, and/or quantity of evidence. |
Accomplishes Level 3 AND goes beyond in some significant way, such as suggesting additional evidence beyond the activity that would further influence choices in specific ways, OR questioning the source, validity, and/or quantity of evidence & explaining how it influences choice. |
|
3 |
Provides major objective reasons AND supports each with relevant & accurate evidence. |
Makes a tradeoff using at least two perspectives or options AND provides major objective reasons, supported by relevant & accurate evidence, for each option. |
|
2 |
Provides some objective reasons AND some supporting evidence BUT at least one reason is missing and/or part of the evidence is incomplete. |
States at least two perspectives or options AND provides some objective reasons using some relevant evidence BUT reasons are incomplete and/or part of the evidence is missing; OR only one complete and accurate option has been provided. |
|
1 |
Provides only subjective reasons (opinions) for choices and/or uses inaccurate or irrelevant evidence from the activity. |
States at least one perspective/option BUT only provides subjective reasons (opinions) and/or uses inaccurate or irrelevant evidence. |
|
0 |
Response missing, illegible or lacks reasons AND offers no evidence to support decision made. |
Response missing, illegible or lacks reasons AND offers no evidence to support decision made. |
|
X |
Student had no opportunity to respond. |
|